Претражи овај блог

Основни подаци о мени

Моја слика

Campo Belo São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil

...As you read about Bosnia and Kosovo in your daily newspapers I remind you of the words of Socrates spoken at his trial in his own defence: "I do not know what effect my accusers have had upon you gentlemen but for my own part I was almost carried away by them; their arguments were so convincing. On the other hand scarcely a word of what they said was true."....

субота, 19. март 2011.

This Is Not A War - The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan

This Is Not A War - The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan

Click here to find out more!

This Is Not A War

19 Mar 2011 01:04 pm


P M Carpenter makes the case:

Here, though, to somewhat repeat myself, is the overarching point: I don't know how to change the real world, and neither does Obama. There are domestic politics in play, like it or not. There are diplomatic politics in play, like it or not. There are regional transformations to be pondered and weighed together and separately, like them or not. There are some bad friends to be protected and many good allies to be assuaged, like it or not. And there is the stupidity of ideology and uniform answers and the nimble flexibility of pragmatism and nuance, the first of which Obama rejects, the second of which he embraces.

Does that guarantee a splendid outcome? Of course not. But that's the real if regrettable world in which Obama operates, and most blogospheric commentators do not.

Let me say two things in response. My terrible judgment on Iraq can legitimately be used to ignore whatever I might have to say on Libya. Fine. And there is no doubt that it is easier to be a blogger than a statesman, reacting to complex events and sudden crises in real time. And I do not question the integrity of the process that led to this fateful decision, or the good intentions of those, from Samantha Power to Susan Rice, who pushed for it. I know there is no clear linear path through this riveting and unnerving period in Arab history.

My fear is the following: that, when push comes to shove, there will be no real Arab cover for this action, by which I mean Arab arms openly engaged against Libya under an Arab flag. I also suspect that Britain and France don't have the depth of military resources to do this over the long haul, and their publics, like the American one, may balk if or when the war becomes more complex or Qaddafi outlasts it. The US is the final guarantor here. And it is a heavy obligation with unknowable consequences. That's why this is so unnerving:

The president had a caveat, though. The American involvement in military action in Libya should be limited — no ground troops — and finite. “Days, not weeks,” a senior White House official recalled him saying.

So lets take him at his word, shall we? The US commitment will be "days, not weeks." How long before we hear the phrase "weeks, not months"? And how, in this bankrupt country, will this be paid for? What will be cut to budget for this? Or is this new war - begun without even the pretense of consulting the Congress or the country - going to be "off-budget" like the last two?

(Photo: Smoke billows after a Libyan jet bomber crashed after being shot down in Benghazi on March 19, 2011 as Libya's rebel stronghold came under attack, with at least two air strikes and sustained shelling of the city's south sending thick smoke into the sky. By Patrick Baz/Getty.)

The Biggest Story in Photos

The 2011 Iditarod Sled Dog Race

Mar. 18 2011

Sully's Recent Keepers

The Imperial President

It makes sense only as an emotional response to an emergency.

Forget History (Or Not)

The US is broke and its military over-extended.

American Decline And The Right

Conservatives are grasping at a fading US hegemony.

Inequality And The Right

It's about political stability and cohesion.

Palin And Trig

There she goes again.

Andrew Sullivan
from the Magazine

Dear President Bush,

Americans want, and need, to move on from the debate over torture in Iraq and Afghanistan and close…

Why I Blog

For centuries, writers have experimented with forms that evoke the imperfection of thought, the…

My Big Fat Straight Wedding

What’s the difference between homosexuals and heterosexuals? In matters outside the bedroom,…

More Andrew Sullivan from the Magazine

Search the Dish


To see what is in front of one's nose needs a constant struggle

— George Orwell

E-Mail Andrew | Bio

Editor Andrew Sullivan

Executive Editors Patrick Appel, Chris Bodenner

Senior Editor Conor Friedersdorf

Associate Editor Zoe Pollock

Subscribe Now

SAVE 59%! 10 issues JUST $2.45 PER COPY


Sign up to receive our three free newsletters

This Week on TheAtlantic.com (sample)

This Month in The Atlantic (sample)

5 Best Columns from The Atlantic Wire (sample)

I want to receive updates from our partners and sponsors

Site Meter

Нема коментара:

Постави коментар